CRPS Can Be a Scheduled Member Injury | Cutler Law Firm, P.C.
Cutler Law Firm, P.C.

CRPS Can Be a Scheduled Member Injury

On November 13, 2026, a Deputy Commissioner made an important conclusion in Gilpin v. FS, Inc., File No. 24012088.01 (Arb. Dec. Nov. 13, 2026) that could have a substantial impact on the handling and adjudication of claims involving chronic regional pain syndrome, or CRPS.

Since the early 1960s, the Iowa Supreme Court has suggested that because CRPS is a “circulatory ailment” that affects the “entire nervous system,” CRPS is an unscheduled injury. Barton v. Nevada Poultry Co., 110 N.W.2d 660 (Iowa 1961). Thirty years later, the Iowa Court of Appeals specifically adopted this rule in Collins v. Dept. of Human Serv., 529 N.W.2d 627 (Iowa Ct. App. 1995). For the past 30 years, the Iowa Workers’ Compensation Commissioner has held that an injured worker with CRPS necessarily sustains an unscheduled injury and is therefore entitled to permanent partial disability benefits based on an industrial disability analysis.

In 2024, the Iowa Supreme Court opened the door for a departure from Barton and Collins. In Delaney v. Second Injury Fund of Iowa, 6 N.W.3d 714 (Iowa 2024), the injured worker developed lymphedema (a vascular condition) in her leg after a knee surgery. The Supreme Court held that the Commissioner was wrong to conclude that all vascular injuries are necessarily unscheduled injuries. Whether an injury is scheduled or unscheduled is a fact-based inquiry that must be determined on a case-by-case basis. Sometimes, an injury to a bodily system may extend beyond a localized area and result in an unscheduled injury. In other cases, an injury to a bodily system (e.g., nervous system, vascular system, skeletal system, etc.) only impacts a discrete part of the body and does not result in an unscheduled injury.

On November 13, 2026, citing Delaney, a Deputy Commissioner concluded that the worker’s CRPS was a scheduled member injury. Gilpin v. FS, Inc., File No. 24012088.01 (Arb. Dec. Nov. 13, 2026). Importantly, the medical evidence showed that the worker’s CRPS diagnosis and symptoms were confined to her right lower extremity. Although the worker had a permanent spinal cord stimulator implanted in her spine, the need for the spinal cord stimulator was due to pain in her right lower extremity. There was no evidence the CRPS extended beyond the right lower extremity. In addition, it appears that no physician had assigned permanent impairment or permanent work restrictions for any body part outside of the right lower extremity. If a physician had assigned permanent impairment or work restrictions for body parts outside of the right leg, we suspect the result could have been different.

It is important to note that Gilpin is currently an agency arbitration decision that is not binding precedent in other cases before the agency. We suspect Gilpin will be appealed to the Commissioner, and possibly to the appellate courts. Nevertheless, it is an important decision that practitioners should be aware of, as it could have a substantial impact on the way CRPS claims are handled and adjudicated in the future.

As always, please contact any of our attorneys with questions regarding this or other workers’ compensation matters.

© 2026 Cutler Law Firm, P.C. All rights reserved.